Ancient & Modern* Poem by Neil Young

Ancient & Modern*

Rating: 4.8


How well the old sits with the new,
Giving what is minimal
An interest and theme;
A neutral canvas
Where there is everything to learn.

How weak the new fits with the old,
Cheapening the substantial,
Marking out a struggle
Between bold principles
And inevitable entropy.

COMMENTS OF THE POEM
Bill Thomas 16 May 2008

Mmmmmmm - the hymnologist in me picks up a lot here which you may not intend... but then again..... well done!

0 0 Reply
Neil Marsden 17 October 2008

A very clever and intelligent poem that is a lot deper than it first appears! Well done! Neil.

0 0 Reply
Wojja Fink 03 April 2009

old substantial words linger in new speech...............thoughtful and appreciative....John

0 0 Reply
oguz Anil 19 October 2009

Tks very much mr.Young i enjoyed them all profoundly astonishing

0 0 Reply
oguz Anil 19 October 2009

Tks for the poems mr.Young i enjoyed it great poem

0 0 Reply
Dr Antony Theodore 04 May 2017

the old teaches and guides the new. at the same time one shall not hold on to the old fanatically. nice theme dear poet. thank u

0 0 Reply
Neil Young 02 February 2012

@Ramesh Rai: That depends if its made out of MDF or chipbard with a melamine coating, rickety legs etc... Give me solid oak anyday.

1 0 Reply
Ramesh Rai 01 February 2012

though old is gold. but new is not so weak. nice poem.

0 0 Reply
Smoky Hoss 05 December 2011

I do like this one; and your explanation (below) is helpful, thanks.

1 0 Reply
Neil Young 25 June 2010

In response to the previous comment by Ruth Walters: I suppose it does depend on the interaction between the two. Think of the poem in terms of the cheapening insubstantial state of things in a contemporary setting against the bold and substantial in a historical sense. One could refer to furniture in a room, a selection of hymns bound together, old architecture against new, the struggle of new and old ideas and/or a watering down of standards. I use the word entropy to mean the eventual decay that everything submits to in the end. I hope this clarifies.

1 0 Reply
READ THIS POEM IN OTHER LANGUAGES
Close
Error Success