You Ask: Why Winter? Poem by Emmanuel George Cefai

You Ask: Why Winter?



You ask: Why Winter?
Winter gives warmth to my verse
And as no other season it gives
Birth
To beauty in its hoar and horrid wonders
In its rattling cold and sundry thunders
Its rain that floods woods and vales
And hamlets trembling small:
O Winter! Winter!

COMMENTS OF THE POEM
Daniel Brick 23 December 2014

It's seems as if your attitude to winter changes in the course of the poem - When you initially say winter gives warmth to your poems I gather you mean the reading of them is a warm and wonderful experience, perhaps shared with others, but then you start listing the hazards of winter and conclude with calling it twice almost as if you are pleading - Enough already, winter! At the end of his ODE TO THE WEST WIND, Shelley issues a prophecy: IF WINTER COMES, CAN SPRING BE FAR BEHIND? In some climates like mine YES1 VERY FAR BEHIND!

3 0 Reply
Daniel Brick 15 December 2014

I am surprised by the sheer acceptance of winter in this poem. You do mention destructive winter storms but there is no fear or impatience expressed. But you are a denizen of the Mediterranean world. Have you ever experienced winter in a landscape as far north as my Minnesota? ? The grip of cold (bone-chilling cold!) and deluge of snow are truly relentless. But I like your poem just because it is positive about winter. In my poem A NEW LIFE STAGE SIX I put my protagonist much further north - 300 -400 miles from where I live in the south, yet he writes in a letter WINTER IS HARD, BUT NOT/WITHOUT ITS COLD DELIGHTS. Your poem is one with COLD DELIGHTS as well.

2 0 Reply
READ THIS POEM IN OTHER LANGUAGES
Close
Error Success