Poetics and Poetry Discussion
Marti Mylin- Word Junkie
(10/27/2013 7:01:00 PM)
| Read 1 reply
Below is JC's post from above, (copied in minus the insults) , and thereby " digestible" , because it can be absorbed without raising ire:
" Oh, and, Damian, if you happen to be Lamont, what I say above goes double for you. The more I look at " Damien's" comments above, the more they sound like your typically Lamontian poetic views.
Words removed: " narrow, mulish and mechanical"
Still opioniated, but less rude. I am sure this will piss you off, JC, so go ahead and commence assailing me.Replies for this message:
(10/27/2013 5:20:00 PM)
He's harsh because that classical, finer view of poetry you posted, de-legitimizes his own work. I understand his frustration completely. Unfortunately for JC, until Bukowski is considered to be a better poet than Robert Frost, until Hass is greater than Heaney, certain types of free verse will always be critically second rate, whether its 'dominant' or not. Reality TV is dominant in our culture too, presently. But we all know how bad and schmaltzy most of it is. -LP
(10/27/2013 3:43:00 PM)
| Read 2 replies
I am not Lamont, Quite happy-to stand my own corner. you sound quite harsh in your comments, and obviously feel strongly about The subject which I respect. However the fact you feel my views are dated, does not make them any less valid.
I took on board what you said about reading " Free Verse" An Essay On Prosody" by Charles Hartman. Having read the first chapter I am not converted, but find it an interesting other point of view. I will reserve judgement when I have given it a fair chance.
Damian CranneyReplies for this message:
(10/27/2013 9:16:00 PM)
When one has cultivated, studied, supportable views, its fine to be entrenched. I'm not threatened by anyone's criticism, literary views, or poetry. -LP
(10/27/2013 5:14:00 PM)
Damien, if you're really reading Hartman, I suspect you're not Lamont. Being asked to question his entrenched views is too threatening to him. Read ALL of Hartman, and we can talk. Oh, and if your ... more
- Lamont Palmer (10/27/2013 9:16:00 PM) Post reply